Carmex vs. Chapstick: Which is Better?

Sharing is caring!

The lips care routine is as important as skin care even though most often neglect this face. Your lips also face problems from extreme temperatures that affect them.

Other factors, such as food, drink, and lip products, also influence its appearance. Chapped, dry, and cracked lips can occur if your lips are not well taken care of.

Lips balm is the go-to regimen to cater to most lip problems and rejuvenate its appearance.

It will keep your lips looking fresh and healthy. Since there are many lip balm products in the market, you might find it confusing to choose the best for yourself.

Let’s review two of the best lip balm products: Carmex and Chapstick, establishing their similarities and differences to choose the best one.

If you find this interesting, read along.

Carmex vs. Chapstick: Which is Better?

Overview of the Brands

Carmex and Chapstick are staples in the lip balms industry. They develop products that care for the lips and keep them moistened throughout the seasons.

Carmex was first produced in 1937 by Alfred Woelbing as a core sore remedy in a metal container.

The product has developed much since then, and it’s now trying beyond cold sore. It’s packed in small jars or tins of 3 or 4oz, which can be white or red.

The lip balm works well for moisturizing and soothing the lips. It gives a smooth layer that absolves into the skin very well.

Beyond the lips, it applies to skin, bug bites, and cuts. It helps maintain skin flexibility by retaining moisture. Carmex is ideal for anybody but is most beneficial to dry, chapped lips.

Furthermore, Carmex can reduce irritation and pain from acne, windburn, or other skin problems.

The product is available on the brand’s website and other online stores such as Walmart and Amazon.

On the other hand, Chapstick was invented by the Company Smith. The brand came after Carmex, but it’s his strong competitor.

Chapstick makes lip balms that can help moisturize and hydrate dry, chapped lips.

Chapstick is available in different flavors, including cherry, Wintergreen, almond, peppermint, and cool spearmint.

So, customers can choose flavors that suit their preferences while moisturizing their lips. It’s suitable for any age range, but children and older individuals consume it the most.

It’s also available in popular online retail stores like Target, Amazon, Walmart, and Walgreen.


The ingredients available in a lip balm are the significant criteria that determine if it’ll be effective. Both brands use ingredients that are beneficial to the lips.

The active ingredients are pretty similar, even though the combinations might differ.

Carmen contains cocoa butter, mineral oil, paraffin wax, petroleum jelly, menthol, and beeswax.

The medicated lips balm also has Carmex Triple Force Formula, which protects the lips against cold, wind, and dry weather. The product is free of artificial flavors and coloring, gluten, and animal fats.

Paraffin is present to keep it waterproof and protect it from melting off in the sun or heat.

The mineral oil is the moisturizing ingredient, and the cocoa butter is the thickener. Beeswax serves as the emollient ingredient. The product is non-comedogenic, so it doesn’t clog pores.

Chapstick also has a wide range of ingredients.

The active ingredients include cocoa butter, castor oil, beeswax, carnauba wax, petrolatum, lanolin, and paraffin wax.

The company produces different lip products, and the ingredients differ. Some are made with soft formulas, while others are made of hard formulas.

The company also uses numerous chemicals to develop the products, including citric acid, alcohols, Butylated Hydroxytoluene, and glycol stearate.

These ingredients are great lips moisturizers but might cause some side effects for sensitive skin.

Ease of Usage

Both products are relatively easy to use. Carmex requires a twist-and-push method to open it. You’ll need to twist, push then rotate it again to open it.

The content is easily applicable. It’s not sticky, and it sinks well into the skin.

In contrast, Chapstick uses a turn-and-twist method to open it.

You need to be dexterous and have sharpening skills. Your finger will need to close it using a cap to access the content.

Carmex vs. Chapstick: Comparison

  • Carmex is less greasy
  • Chapstick is cheaper
  • Carmex has a wide range of ingredients used. The added menthol gives cooler sensation
  • Carmex offers additional benefits beyond moisturizing chapped lips.
  • Carmex has a better scent
  • Both products are effective

Carmex vs. Chapstick: Which is Better?

Both products are excellent, and their performance is similar. Also, there isn’t much difference except for the price factor.

However, Carmex offers added advantages to the lips beyond revitalization due to its wide range of ingredients.

It’s also effective in treating other skin problems. Hence, Carmex has the edge over Chapstick in performance scores.

Which Brand Should You Choose?

The best brand to choose will depend on personal preferences. There are benefits to buying either of the products.

If you are on a tight budget, Chapstick lip balm should be your priority.

However, if you fancy an all-inclusive lips balm without minding the budget, Carmex is your ideal option.

Whichever one you choose, you should rest assured you’re getting a good product.

Related Posts:

We earn commissions if you purchase thru our link. Majority of products aren’t tested by the site owner (except a few). Content is from the research and feedback of users.