Elta Md vs. Supergoop: Which is Better?

Sharing is caring!

We can all agree sunscreen is an essential skincare product that should be present in our skincare routine, especially in the summertime.

Sunscreen will help protect the skin against harsh UV rays.

But Seriously, can we talk about sunscreen without referencing Elta Md and Supergoop? It’s probably not possible.

These products are fundamentals in the world of sunscreen.

You’ll find them in every sunscreen aisle of local beauty stores. These brands produce sunscreens that are reliable all year round.

In this article, we’ll be comparing these two best-sellers brands, discussing their similarities and differences so we can establish the one that suits your skin best.

Both brands produce a wide range of popular sunscreens that offer unique features.

Hence, We’ll use their respective best products: Elta Md UV Clear Sunscreen and Supergoop Unseen Sunscreen.

Let’s get started.

Elta Md vs. Supergoop: Which is Better?

About the Products

Elta Md UV Clear Sunscreen is an SPF 46 dermatologist-recommended sensitive skin sunscreen.

It is formulated mainly for acne-prone and sensitive skin.

The product performance is beyond average. It is a well-rounded product that improves the skin over time.

It prevents and reverses sun damage from the skin, thus promoting healthy skin tone and appearance.

The product hydrates the skin without causing any irritation or breakout. It leaves the skin hydrated and moisturized for long hours.

However, it’s not waterproof, so it’s a daily sunscreen and not a waterproof sunscreen.

The average product rating on Amazon is high, meaning customer satisfaction. Most customers attest to its effectiveness and is often recommended by dermatologists.

A few attributes of the product include:

  • Soothes and protects acne-prone skin
  • 9.0% transparent zinc oxide
  • Antioxidant protection to tackle free radicals related to IR and UV
  • Protects against burning and aging rays.

When you talk about a genuinely invisible, scentless, and weightless sunscreen, you’re describing the attributes of Supergoop Unseen Sunscreen.

It’s an original SPF 40 and an antioxidant-rich product with an oil-free formula that soothes the skin and gives broad-spectrum protection.

The product is non-greasy and doesn’t leave a white cast. It’s ideal for all skin types, making it a unique product. It’s also an excellent makeup-gripping primer so that it can give more coverage and a natural look.

It is available on the brand’s website and other online retail outlets such as Sephora, Amazon, Nordstrom, and Target.

Some attributes of the product include:

  • Moisturizing and hydrating properties
  • Great makeup-gripping primer
  • Non-greasy
  • Weightless, scentless, and invisible
  • Color-cancel potentially damaging blue light

Ingredients Review

Elta Md UV Clear Sunscreen contains chemical sunscreen ingredients even though it’s a mineral-based sunscreen. It has 9% zinc oxide(mineral) and 7.5% octinoxate(chemical).

The product is also free of fragrance, oil, paraben, gluten, and allergens. Hence, it’s an excellent option for sensitive skin.

The ingredients list contains elements that are beneficial to the skin. However, some studies have linked ingredients such as octinoxate and oxybenzone to hormonal issues.

Supergoop is also a clean skincare brand. It’s coral reef-friendly and cruelty-free. It’s packed the following potent ingredients:

  • Active Ingredients – Avobenzone, 3%. Octocrylene 4%, Octisalate 5%, Homosalate 8%.
  • Red algae – to color-cancel potentially damaging visible light like blue light
  • Frankincense – to assist the skin to be resilient. It also gives a soothing effect.
  • Meadowfoam Oil – increases hydration levels to ensure a healthy skin texture.

Elta Md vs. Supergoop: Pros And Cons

Pros And Cons Of Elta Md

  • Get dries quickly
  • No white cast
  • Great for sensitive skin
  • Free of harmful substances like paraben and oil
  • Non-comedogenic, i.e., doesn’t block pores
  • Layers greatly under makeup
  • Unscented


  • Poor scent (medicinal)
  • Not Brydie clean
  • Contains controversial ingredients

Pros And Cons Of Supergoop

  • Transparent and truly invisible
  • Lightweight and very comfortable
  • No white cast or greatness
  • Doesn’t pill


  • Relatively pricier

Elta Md vs. Supergoop: Comparison

The following are points to consider to differentiate between the two products:

  • Both products are lightweight, fragrance and oil-free
  • Elta Md UV is a mineral sunscreen, while Supergoop Unseen is a chemical sunscreen
  • Supergoop is ideal for all skin types, while Elta Md works better for acne-prone and sensitive skin
  • Supergoop has more clean ingredients than Elta Md. Elta Md is not reef-safe.
  • Elta Md is cheaper than Supergoop

Which is Better that You Can Choose?

Both products are excellent and effective for preventing sunburn, skin cancer, and early skin aging. They also are effective for hydrating and moisturizing the skin.

Generally, it’s hard to find any negative reviews about these products as they are reliable for sun protection and other skin benefits.

There’s an insignificant distinction between the two products except for the skin type and the ingredients factors.

Concerning these factors, we think Supergoop might be the better choice. It contains the best ingredients and is ideal for all skin types.

However, the best product for you will depend on your preferences since both have different unique features.

If you have acne-prone or sensitive skin and seek a great product that won’t dent your wallet, you will be better off with Elta Md UV Clear Facial Sunscreen.

Similarly, Supergoop Unseen Sunscreen will be the one for you if you seek a product that works for all skin types and offers risk-free ingredients.

Related Posts:

We earn commissions if you purchase thru our link. Majority of products aren’t tested by the site owner (except a few). Content is from the research and feedback of users.