Irish Spring vs Dove Soap: Which Is Better?

Irish Spring and Dove have been around for quite a while.

Both brands have their fans but then, why do people choose each one? What do they have in common and how are they different?

What if you decide to try one but don’t know which one is better? Then this comparison is for you.

Keep reading to know what differentiates these brands and which one might be more suitable for you.

Irish Spring vs Dove Soap: Which Is Better?

Dove Go Fresh Beauty Bar vs Irish Spring Deodorant Bar Soap

These 2 products have more differences than they do similarities.

The Dove Go Fresh Beauty Bar does not promote itself primarily as a soap.

Unlike the Irish Spring Deodorant Bar Soap, although it does still offer cleansing properties.

Let’s look at the major differences.

Dove Go Fresh Beauty Bar

The first and major difference is the formulation of the bars.

The Dove Beauty bar contains 25% moisturizer, by far the highest active ingredient.

Its primary job is to leave your skin feeling softer and more supple, the cleansing aspect is almost secondary.

Almost but not quite.

While conventional soaps can strip the skin of essential oils and leave it feeling dry, the Dove Go bar contains milder cleansers and more gentle exfoliants than conventional bar soap.

It also has true rejuvenating ingredients like Green Tea, Cucumber and Moisturizer to nourish and refresh the skin.

This is primarily a beauty product, suitable for daily use, with bonus cleansing properties.

Irish Spring Deodorant Bar Soap

The Deodorant Bar Soap from Irish Spring, however, is a soap first and foremost.

Available in up to 7 different formulations its primary job is to clean.

While other ingredients will eliminate bacteria and deodorize your body leaving you smelling fresh and feeling clean it is, above all else, a soap.

It is designed to cleanse and gently exfoliate while simultaneously deodorizing.

The various varieties offer some different formulations for slightly different outcomes.

This includes more aggressive exfoliation, extra moisturizing and ‘Sports Strength’. But it is, primarily, a cleansing soap.

Pricing

Because of its different properties and function, the Dove Go may cost you a little more.

But bargains can be found online if you’re willing to search a little.

However, it is a product with a different agenda to the Irish Spring bar.

Dove Go has more complex moisturizing components than conventional bar soap.

And since it’s a true beauty product, you are going to pay a little more for it but your skin is worth it.

Irish Spring, on the other hand, is much cheaper. And that’s not to say it isn’t a good soap. In fact, there is a lot of good demand for the soap.

In terms of costs, here is what you need to know:

An 8-pack of Dove Original Beauty Bar Soap, where each bar weighs in about 3.75 oz, is priced anywhere from $10 to $12, with prices and availability varying online.

A 12-pack of Irish Spring Original Clean Bar Soap, about 3.75 oz per bar, is the better value at $6.99 at Target.

Currently, it is not available through Amazon.

Other products sold by both companies tend to vary in price.

So you may want to adjust your budget and check for yourself, considering what your needs are.

Ingredients:

Going by each of the company’s basic bar soaps, they each have similar ingredients.

Dove’s has the following:

Sodium Lauroyl Isethionate, Stearic Acid, Lauric Acid, Sodium Oleate, Water (Eau), Sodium Isethionate, Sodium Stearate, Cocamidopropyl Betaine, Fragrance (Parfum), Sodium Laurate, Tetrasodium Etidronate, Tetrasodium EDTA, Sodium Chloride, Kaolin or (ou) Titanium Dioxide.

And Irish Spring has the following:

Sodium Laurate/Linoleate/Oleate/Palmitate, Water/Eau, Glycerin, Fragrance/Parfum, Sodium Chloride, Charcoal Powder, Tetrasodium EDTA, Etidronic Acid, Green 8, Green 3.

As you can see, they use similar ingredients with a few differences here and there.

There is not much here that can point to one being better than the other.

Varieties of Scent

Another way that the two products are different is in the variety of soaps that are on offer.

Irish Spring has just 7 sents on offer, including one for sensitive skin (Aloe Mist Deodorant Bar Soap) and for those who are competitive in sports (Sports Strength Antibacterial Bar Soap).

However, Dove has a myriad of soaps on offer, with over 17 different options, ranging from different sents to care for different types of skin.

This means that the end user can have as many or as few options as they like.

Style

Both of these soap companies offer different types of soaps for the modern consumer, but the way that they market these soaps is very different.

For Dove, they tend to market their soaps to women and families, as many of the soaps have what can be considered, softer, more feminine sounding names like ‘Glowing beauty Bar’ or ‘Gentile Exfoliating Beauty Bar’.

The packaging itself is colored in lighter tones and has images that connotate a more relaxed state.

These terms tend to connotate a softer, more feminine approach to skin care, as though the person is washing away the stress and relaxing after a long day.

Irish Spring Soap, on the other hand, seems to be going for a more gender-neutral tone.

They have names like ‘Moisture Blast Bar Soap’ and ‘Sports Strength Bar Soap’.

This is punctuated by their green packaging and water graphics, making the customer believe that these soaps are, at the very least, more gender neutral, and can be used by anyone.

Related Posts:

We earn commissions if you purchase thru our link. Majority of products aren’t tested by the site owner (except a few). Content is from the research and feedback of users.