Murad vs Proactiv: Which of the Two Brands Is Best for You?

If you’re looking for an acne-fighting package with the possibility of good results, you should consider Murad vs Proactiv. Both brands are great for effective acne-fighting products.

However, how do you choose between both?

Because both of them require a monthly payment, it may not be economical to subscribe to both like you can do if you’re buying shampoo or lotion from two brands.

Therefore, this article will go into what each brand can offer you and how you can benefit.

Murad vs Proactiv (Acne Products)

Having acne can be very negative for a person’s self-esteem. Fortunately, there are many treatments available for this condition.

In 2016, a survey was made in which it was found out that 85% of people had to deal with it at some point in their lives.

In this article, we will talk about how Murad compares to Proactive when it comes to getting rid of acne.

Murad vs Proactiv (Ingredients)

The main difference between them is the ingredients they contain. Murad is composed of salicylic acid while Proactive is made up of benzoyl peroxide, or adapalene.

To be more exact, the Proactiv Renewing Cleaner has 2.5% of benzoyl peroxide. On the other hand, the amount of salicylic found in Murad’s Clarifying Cleanser helps at keeping the skin clear.

And the glycolic acid found in Murad’s Exfoliating Acne Treatment aids at dissolving dirt that may be retained due to pore-clogging as well as dead skin cells.

Murad vs Proactiv (Effectiveness)

A lot of people have reported success using both products. However, Murad is known to work mostly for milder cases of acne while Proactive may work for harsher cases.

Murad and their Products

Murad Clear Skin Regimen

One of Murad’s most popular products is the Murad Clear Skin Regimen, which contains three different products. This includes the Oil-Control Mattifier, which helps to control oil and reduce the shine of the face.

The Clarifying Cleanser helps in washing out the impurities on the face so it becomes radiant and blemish-free.

The Acne Clearing Solution is the main product and is designed to combat acne. The entire kit is priced at a little under $100 and can last you up to 3 months.

This is a very reasonable time frame, not only because it makes for a good investment but also long enough to determine if you’re seeing results or not.

Ingredient in Murad Clear Skin Regimen

Like it’s mentioned elsewhere in this article, the main kit from Murad comes with salicylic acid.

This ingredient is responsible for drying up oily skin with few side effects as commonly seen with other ingredients like benzoyl peroxide.

How to Use Murad Clear Skin Regimen

According to the company, this cleanser and acne clearing solution should be used in the morning and evening.

The Mattifier is not to be used in the evening, it should be limited to your morning regime.

Also, if you’re buying from Murad, you can follow their promotions where they offer different discounts. This can save you money and is best for those who want to treat their acne on budget.

Results from Using Murad Clear Skin Regimen

While many people have claimed that they were able to clear the blemishes on their skin in a short time, others have found no result or some side effects.

Therefore, you need to look through their other ingredients to see if there is any that can cause reactions to your skin. And also decide, before buying, if their product is a good match for your skin.

Proactiv and their Products

In terms of product offering, Proactiv seems to have more products on offer than Murad. This includes their Proactiv Original, Proactiv+, and ProactivMD.

Proactiv Original

The first one, which is the original version, is suitable for fighting acne on teen faces.

However, it uses benzoyl peroxide as the primary ingredient, which may cause some dryness especially if you already have dry or combination skin.

The Plus version uses salicylic acid along with benzoyl peroxide, so the effect of dryness may not be as much as you can find in the first one.


The Proactiv+ is a skin-smoothing exfoliator, so if you’re looking for fresh, smooth and no-blemish skin, you can try this out.

The last system/product includes fash wash and daily moisturizer that can be used for cleansing and hydration.

Compared to Murad, however, the Proactiv product may cost you more.

This is because most of their products come in smaller packages. This means you’ll have to order more before you get the amount you may need for your skin conditions.

Murad vs Proactiv (Side Effects)

Murad is generally gentler on the skin since Benzoyl peroxide can cause redness which makes it a bad choice for people with sensitive skin.

Also, people using Proactiv should avoid sun exposure and apply sunscreen to battle UV rays.

Murad vs Proactiv (Cost)

While prices may vary, you can get the Proactive system for around $20 a month. This includes three products.

Other Proactiv products are also available and if you want to buy them you can purchase them for an extra cost.

The Murad system is around $30 a month. It contains three main products and it also comes with a clarifying mask product and a spot treatment.

Bottom Line

As we can conclude, if your acne is not that bad and you don’t want to get a temporary redness on your skin, you should go with Murad products.

On the other hand, if your acne is too bad you should buy Proactiv instead.

Since both of them are priced fairly equally, you should base your decision based on your skin type and current acne condition.

However, if you want to take the fastest route you can try Proactiv at first since your acne may land on the moderate side of things. Both of them can be bought over the counter.

Related: Is Tresemme Better than L’Oreal?

We earn commissions if you purchase thru our link. Majority of products aren’t tested by the site owner (except a few). Content is from the research and feedback of users.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *