Nioxin vs Rogaine: Which One Is BEST for Hair Loss?

Sharing is caring!

Hair loss is common among people, even though it takes different forms in the two sexes. Men experience it as baldness while the condition is called hair thinning in women.

If you’re reading this article, you probably are suffering from this problem. If that’s the case, then I implore you to read this article. Carefully. It’ll help you decide what to choose between Nioxin and Rogaine.

Why Compare Nioxin and Rogaine?

These are two of the biggest names that pop up when people discuss hair loss.

However, there has been a lot of mixed-up between them and lots of misrepresentation flying about. If you’re suffering from hair loss, should you go for Rogaine or Nioxin?

When is Nioxin better than Rogaine and vice versa? All of these things can confuse anyone that just needs a solution to their hair thinning problem.

If you have never used any of these products, it’s in your best interest to understand what they both do. This is why it’s important to do your homework before committing to any product.

In this article, you’ll be reading a side-by-side comparison of Nioxin and Rogaine. You’ll learn what they do and which one is better than the other and in what instances.

Also Read:

Nioxin vs Rogaine: The Differences

The differences between Rogaine and Nioxin are clear. While Rogaine helps you treat and combat hair loss, Nioxin helps in preventing it.

Nioxin should be used for hair thickening while Rogaine is suitable for hair regrowth. Therefore, Nioxin is a better treatment for thinning hair while Rogaine is great for male pattern baldness.

Therefore, if you’re already experiencing hair loss, you might want to get Rogaine. However, if you’re only looking to prevent hair loss, then Nioxin is better positioned than Rogaine.

Nioxin vs Rogaine: Which One Is BEST for Hair Loss?

Nioxin Scalp Recovery Anti-Dandruff Shampoo

Nioxin vs Rogaine
Nioxin Scalp Recovery Anti-Dandruff Shampoo

This is a scalp recovery system that consists of a three-part regime. This includes the Medicated Cleanser, Moisturizing Conditioner, and a Soothing Serum.

All of these are supposed to work together to bring your scalp back to normal.

Nioxin is not just a shampoo. It’s a 3-part system consisting of a shampoo, conditioner, and scalp treatment.

According to the manufacturer, shampoo helps create a healthy scalp environment so that hair growth can happen.

However, many have questioned the effectiveness of the system, citing numerous claims that debunk the beautifully crafted message of the manufacturer that their product is the best.

The truth of the matter is that some people have overwhelmingly positive reviews of the product while many don’t see it in a positive light.


If you already have a serious hair loss condition, you will not get anywhere with Nioxin. It’s more of a prevention system than a treatment solution.

It can help clean your scalp. And refurnish it with nutrients. However, it isn’t a strong hair loss treatment. Rogaine is better suited for treating the problem.

Nioxin Is Not A Hair Regrowth Product

You may have come across reviews that state you can easily regrow hair using Nioxin. This isn’t true. The company behind the product clearly stated that it is not a hair loss product.

As such, it should only be used as a hair and scalp care regimen to improve your scalp health.

While that can help in the overall improvement of the condition, it’s not to be taken as the solution or sole treatment for hair thinning.

If you’re experiencing hair thinning, you need a stronger and more proactive product like Rogaine or any other effective solution.

What Can the Shampoo Do for YOU?

The active ingredient is Pyrithione Zinc and green tea extract. Green tea can support hair growth or regrowth, which is backed by some studies.

The foremost recommended ingredient for anti-dandruff shampoo is the Zinc Pyrithione, which is known as an effective treatment of seborrheic dermatitis and dandruff.

It has antibacterial properties that are helpful for keeping the hair in a good state. According to the manufacturer, you can start seeing results in the first use. It can be used for all hair types and at different levels of thinning.

A lot of people claim that their shampoos and hair loss products are not FDA approved and Nioxin isn’t making any denial, which makes a lot of people a bit uneasy in using their products.

However, a lot of people are seeing good results from using their products, which is why they’re well-rated. I’ll not recommend them for that reason.

The Rogaine Hair Growth System

There are both men and female solution. THe men solution contains 5% of minoxidil while that of the women contains only 2%.

The version with 5% formula is more potent and likely more effective than the 2% and is only meant for use by men. There is also a 3-month supply since a continuous use of same period is adviced.

This instruction is clear and very important as hair loss may return if stopped before the period ends.

Depending on the cause of the hair loss and the level of it, the time period may be slightly different. It’s also not meant for use for people under the age of 18 years or above the age of 48 years.

When purchased, the package will come with a pamphlet that explains the steps to follow and important data to keep in mind before applying.

Read: Is Garnier Fructis Bad for Your Hair? SHM Answers!

Ingredients of the Rogaine Hair Growth System

Nioxin vs Rogaine
Rogaine Hair Growth System

The active ingredient in the Rogaine system is minoxidil. Other inactive ingredients include glycerin, citric acid, cetyl alcohol, butain, lactic acid, and polysorbate 60.

Minoxidil has been clinically tested to boost hair growth and prevent hairloss or baldness especially in men.

It’s most effective for people who are under the age of 40 years and where the hair loss is still result and not severe. The ingredient helps slow down balding and can possibly cuase permanent regrowth of scalp hair.

Other worth mention is glycerin, which is an emollient for keeping the hair hydrated and moisturized. Citric acid is responsible for adding volume and thickness to hair while also promoting softness and smoothness of the hair.

Note on Rogaine Hair Growth: 

This hair growth system is approved by the FDA as well as clinically-tested to be effective against hair loss.

This is one of the strengths of Rogaine as many others like Nioxin, Viviscal aren’t FDA-approved. It also means that it’s safe to use as long as you following the instructions that come with the package. 

Therefore, if you’re after the hair growth system that’s approved by the FDA, then Rogaine is the better option over Nioxin. It’s also important to have in mind that it’ll take a while before you start to see results with the Rogaine system.

The result should be visible in the 3-month period but don’t be surprised if you didn’t see the result. In that case, you should evaluate your condition. 

Can You Use Nioxin and Rogaine Together?

If you’re reading this, then it means you’re doing something for your hair. That’s a great step towards stopping or at least minimizing your hair loss.

The active ingredient in Rogaine is Minoxidil, which is used for treating baldness in men and hair thinning in women.

Nioxin Scalp Recovery is also good for improving scalp health and can work together with Rogaine.

Therefore, there is nothing stopping you from using the two products together. The unfortunate truth is that using both together does not guarantee results.

Related: Is Nioxin Better than Bosley?

We earn commissions if you purchase thru our link. Majority of products aren’t tested by the site owner (except a few). Content is from the research and feedback of users.


  1. The Nioxin in hair gray dress treatment from Nan has 5% minoxidil. isn’t this the same as Rogaine? I only ask because I already had the Nioxin But if it’s not the same I don’t want to waste my time

    1. sorry for my auto correct. Nioxin men’s hair regrowth treatment has 5% Minoxidil

Comments are closed.