T Gel vs Head and Shoulders: Which One Is the Best for Dandruff?

If you’re reading this article on T Gel vs Head and Shoulders, you’re definitely a few steps towards choosing the right shampoo for dandruff.

If you’re trying to ease itchy scalp or control dandruff, you have a wide variety of options to choose from.

These two popular brands of dandruff shampoo have come a long way in providing good products for people to use to eliminate dandruff.

Out of these two, Head and Shoulders is the most popular. Also, they have a variety of shampoos to choose from, aside from the classic versions from both brands.

The advantage of choosing from either of the two companies is that their shampoos are tried and tested.

The downside is that they have a lot of versions for sensitive hair, oily hair, dry hair, extra volume hair, and a whole lot of others.

But if you can get one that’s suitable for your hair, it can go a long way in helping you clean your hair of psoriasis.

Overall, if you have seborrheic dermatitis, you’ll be better off with T Gel as it’s created specifically for that.

Head and Shoulders have similar properties but might not be as effective compared to Neutrogena T/Gel.

The Science of Switching Shampoos for Dandruff

The products from Neutrogena and Head and Shoulders are both targeted towards people suffering from dandruff.

So, if you’re suffering from this condition, you should at least understand a little background on using products from these brands.

First, it’s not a bad thing to alternate products from different brands.

If you’ve been using shampoo for a while, you might have discovered that the active ingredient in the shampoo you’re using stops working after a while.

This is how most products work: they can stop being effective at any time and there isn’t anything you can do about it.

But you can switch to another brand. Yes, to ensure your treatment continues, switch to another brand and if the new one stops working, go back to the previous one.

T Gel vs Head and Shoulders: Pricing

In terms of pricing, T-gel isn’t that cheap. Just like Nizoral, they might be very expensive for you, especially if you’re on a shoestring budget.

Most people levitate towards the Head and Shoulders as a result of this. You’ll find this is true even when you compare H&S with other brands of shampoos. This is a good thing. You’re paying very little and also getting results.

T Gel vs Head and Shoulders:  Effectiveness

T Gel vs Head and Shoulders

Both T/Gel and H&S are great anti-dandruff shampoos. They’ve been around for a very long time.

And the truth is that many people use them and have found solace in their shampoo.

However, Neutrogena is a better counterpart in terms of performance. When I conducted my research, I found many people prefer the Neutrogena to Head and Shoulders, even though it’s more expensive.

For that, you should go for it if you don’t mind paying a little more.

As mentioned elsewhere in this article, the Neutrogena T/Gel shampoo has a strong smell to it. So, you’ll need a conditioner to manage the scent when you use it.

Active Ingredients

The original version of Neutrogena T-Gel comes with the Coal Tar extract while you’ll find the Head and Shoulders Dandruff Shampoo has Zinc Pyrithione.

The Coal Tar is a medication that is used in treating scaly, itchy scalp. It helps in fighting off fungus and dandruff causing bacterias.

Compared to other ingredients, you can use it for the long term as it’s confirmed to be safe for that. They’re useful when treating hair conditions like dandruff as they help in shedding the dead cells on the scalp.

Pyrithione is similar in its work as it also breaks down skin cells and fungus on the scalp, the two most common culprits of dandruff.

Unlike the T Gel, continuous usage of the Head and Shoulders Dandruff Shampoo can have detrimental effects, so take that in hand.

To use T/Gel, you should massage it onto your scalp and leave it for 5-10 minutes. After that, rinse your hair and scalp thoroughly. Shampoos are easy to wash off the hair so make sure there is no remainder on the hair.

Fortunately, both are safe to use. You’ll find that H&S and Neutrogena states on their bottle label that the product should be used at least twice a week.

You can use any of them two times and it shouldn’t have any negative effects. If you’re afraid of facing some repercussions, then don’t use them every day.


T Gel vs Head and Shoulders
One of the great things about buying beauty products is the avalanche of options you have.

You’re never tied to any brand. And that’s a nice advantage.

Imagine if you get fed up with a brand of shampoo. You can easily replace it with another brand that’s far better.

In the case of T Gel vs Head and Shoulders, you’ll get a lot of varieties. However, Neutrogena’s T Gel has far less variety, compared to Head and Shoulders.

Again, you may find it difficult to find T/Gel in your local store like you would Head and Shoulders.

For many people though, that isn’t a bad thing. And for many others, it can be.

If you’re computer and internet savvy, finding a brand of shampoo you need online is quite easy. So, if you’re looking for the T/Gel, you can get it on popular retailer stores like Amazon.


In terms of fragrance, Head and Shoulders have better scent than T/Gel. This is because of the active ingredient in the original version.

Other versions of the Neutrogena T Gel, like the T/Gel Daily Control have a better and more pleasing scent than the original T/Gel.

Also, the ingredients in newer versions are the same with Head and Shoulders so you can expect similar results. If you prefer to buy the original version of the T Gel but are sensitive to smell, you can try H&S first.

Additional Tips

When it comes to dealing with dry scalp, psoriasis or dandruff, the culprit are sometimes self-inflicted.

The common ones include cigarettes, beer, and one’s overall diet. If you’re a beer-guzzling chimney, it may not help if you get the most expensive shampoo.

Fortunately, most women don’t drink so you’re in the safe boat.

Also, if you can’t manage to eat a healthy diet, you need to actually work on your lifestyle.

There are a lot of advantages you’ll gain from just eating better and avoiding alcoholic drinks.

First, you develop better immunity against different sorts of diseases. Also, any medication you take will likely have a better chance of helping you solve the problem.

All of these apply to treat dandruff too. This isn’t to say that once you do these, dandruff will automatically disappear. But you’ll give the shampoo a chance to work better.

In summary, major lifestyle and diet changes can help in your fight against dandruff.

We earn commissions if you purchase thru our link. Majority of products aren’t tested by the site owner (except a few). Content is from the research and feedback of users.

Sharing is caring!