Vaniply vs Aquaphor: Which Ointment is Best for You?

Sharing is caring!

There is a multitude of treatment gels on the market today. You have the likes of Cerave, Vanicream, Aquaphor, Vaseline, Vaniply, Aveeno, at the forefront.

But some brands are just more effective than others.

Aquaphor and Vaniply, though are manufactured by different companies, look like they have similar features. In this article, I want to compare the Aquaphor Advanced Healing Ointment and the Vaniply Ointment by Vanicream.

Which one is better? Which brand should you choose? Let’s find out. 

Vaniply vs Aquaphor: Which is Better?

Let’s look at some of the differences between Aquaphor and Vaniply. The most important thing to know is that Vaniply is cheaper than Aquaphor even though they are both similar in quality.

Here is a detailed breakdown of each product:

Vaniply Ointment: What Is It? Is It Beneficial?

Vaniply vs Aquaphor
You Can Check this on Amazon

Do you know that it’s the same company that produces the popular Vanicream Ointment is also the same company that is making the Vaniply Ointment? The name might have some pointers, but you probably don’t know.

In essence, the two use the same ointment so this is also likely to be as effective as the Vanicream. The Vaniply has just 1% of dimethicone content, which is a sealant that locks in moisture in the skin while also preventing the loss of it.

The result is skin that’s soft and supple at the same time. Another great thing about the ointment is that it has a relatively short ingredient list, which is always a good thing as opposed to a long list of ingredients.

The shorter the list, the less likely will be any irritants in there. Moreover, it is free from preservatives, dyes, fragrances, which you probably may not see in similar dimethicone protectants.

One of the downsides of this thing is how it feels greasy. Some users complain that it’s very greasy, even after washing their hands.

Vanicream, on the other hand, is lighter and absorbs faster. The Vaniply texture is translucent and doesn’t have any scent to it that might cause irritation or discomfort.

Aside from dimethicone, other inactive ingredients include: C30-45 alkyl methicone, C30-45 olefin, hydrogenated polydecene, microcrystalline wax, polyethylene, silica dimethyl silylate


You can get the ointment from a number of online shopfronts including Amazon, Newegg, eBay, Walmart, and also from Vanicream’s official site.

Make sure to check multiple platforms before buying as the prices are quite different. You may be able to buy cheaper from one of these. 

Aquaphor Advanced Healing Ointment

vaniply vs aquaphor
This is an Ointment…Not a Lotion or Moisturizer

One of the most popular ointments in the market, the Aquaphor Ointment is can help reduce and even clear dry and cracked skin on the feet, lips, arms, elbows, and even baby’s bottom.

The Aquaphor Healing Ointment is a treatment gel that’s formulated to hydrate and heal dry, cracked skin.

Unlike Vaniply, the active ingredient in the ointment is petrolatum and glycerin, which are both humectants that helps draw moisture towards the skin and lock skin’s moisture in so the body is soft.

While the Vaniply Ointment is light, Aquaphor Treatment Gel is thicker but doesn’t have a scent. It’s one of the most recommended for use after surgeries and for managing injuries.

The product is specifically designed for sensitive skin and is often touted as the number 1 dermatologist’s recommended multi-purpose solution. It has 41% of petrolatum, which helps create a barrier on the skin to speed up healing.


Aside from being dermatologist-recommended, the gel is clinically-proven to restore smooth, healthy skin. It is specifically formulated for adults and can be used by both males and females.

Compared to Vaniply, it is cheaper and more affordable and comes in a much bigger jar. If you’re on a budget and looking for the best value for your money, I’ll recommend you check out this ointment.

Final Words: Vaniply or Aquaphor?

Both Aquaphor and Vaniply are good and lots of people have found either of them to be effective. When it comes to ingredients, Vaniply may have an upper hand, thanks to the fewer ingredients used overall.

However, Aquaphor is cheaper and has a bigger jar. This means it’ll cost you less to buy and longer to get through. The best of the two will then be Aquaphor if you don’t want to spend much on your next purchase.

Related Posts:

We earn commissions if you purchase thru our link. Majority of products aren’t tested by the site owner (except a few). Content is from the research and feedback of users.


  1. Cannot seem to find original vaniply or vanicream. I don’t want Tge one with SPF

    When I do find what I want, it costs double what it did (ie 2 in pack instead of 3)

    Do you know of a reliable source for this. I want the tube for the LIPS.

    1. Hi Mooney,

      Where are you?

      And if you’re buying online, have you checked Walmart, Amazon, Sephora, Influenster, Walgreen and the official Vanicream website?

      Let me know…

Comments are closed.