L’Oreal vs Clairol Hair Color: Ultimate Comparison

Sharing is caring!

Hair color has become more than just a cosmetic choice; it’s a form of self-expression.

With multiple brands on the market offering a plethora of shades and formulations, it becomes challenging to make an informed decision.

Two giants in the industry—L’Oreal and Clairol—stand at the forefront, offering products that promise vibrant color, longevity, and healthy hair.

This article aims to dissect the offerings of both brands in-depth and compare them side-by-side to guide you to your ideal pick.

L’Oreal vs Clairol Hair Color: Which is Better?

L’Oreal has been a cornerstone in the beauty industry for over a century.

Founded in Paris, the brand has developed a robust reputation for quality and innovation, always at the forefront of research and technology.

It’s a brand associated with luxury, but it also provides accessible products through its consumer division.

Clairol is a personal care-product division of Coty, focused predominantly on hair coloring and hair care.

Originating in the U.S., Clairol holds a more nostalgic value for many and is recognized for bringing hair color into the mainstream market.


Generally priced at a moderate to high range, L’Oreal is available globally and can be easily found in drugstores as well as high-end department stores.

Clairol is more budget-friendly, and its products are widely accessible in local drugstores across the United States and many other countries.

Hair Color Range

L’Oreal offers an extensive range of hair colors that cater to a broad demographic.

Whether you’re looking for natural hues or more vibrant, fashion-forward shades, there’s a good chance L’Oreal has an option for you.

Additionally, they offer a variety of formats—creams, gels, and mousses—to suit different application preferences.

Clairol’s color range is somewhat more limited compared to L’Oreal but nonetheless offers a variety of shades that mimic natural hair colors exceptionally well.

They also offer specialty lines focusing on different needs like grey coverage and color vibrancy but have fewer adventurous options for those looking to make a bold statement.

Color Retention

L’Oreal prides itself on formulations that promise long-lasting color. Their products often feature patented technologies aimed at sealing color and reducing fade.

While user experiences may vary, generally, the brand has received positive feedback in terms of color longevity.

Clairol also offers long-lasting colors, but some users note that the intensity may start to fade after a few washes, particularly for the more vibrant shades.

However, they do excel in grey coverage, with many users noting that the color stays put on grey strands for an extended period.

Shade Range

One of L’Oreal’s strongest suits is its expansive shade range, offering everything from natural hues to more daring shades.

The brand offers both semi-permanent and permanent options, including lines specifically developed for mature hair.

Clairol also offers a wide variety of shades but leans more towards natural colors. The brand specializes in permanent dyes that are meant to offer full coverage, particularly for grey hair.

User Feedback

One thing that sets L’Oreal apart is its strong online presence, amassing a large volume of user reviews across various platforms.

These reviews generally point to high satisfaction rates, praising the brand for delivering rich color and shiny results. However, there are some grievances about the product’s smell and the occasional adverse reactions for those with sensitive skin.

Clairol also enjoys a solid online reputation, with many users finding it to be a reliable option for at-home hair coloring.

The brand receives positive remarks for its ease of application and effectiveness in covering grey hair. On the downside, some users note that the color can sometimes fade more quickly than desired.

Ethical Practices

In recent years, L’Oreal has invested in sustainable practices, including a commitment to reduce its carbon footprint. The brand has also been working towards cruelty-free certifications and more environmentally friendly packaging, although there’s room for improvement.

Clairol is also becoming more conscious of its environmental impact, focusing on recyclable packaging and cleaner formulations. However, the brand has yet to make significant strides in the cruelty-free department.

Complementary Products

L’Oreal doesn’t just stop at hair color; they offer a full spectrum of hair care products, including shampoos, conditioners, and styling products specifically designed to maintain and extend the life of your hair color.

Clairol similarly provides a range of complementary products but with a narrower focus.

They specialize more in color-protective shampoos and conditioners aimed at sustaining the vibrancy and longevity of their hair dyes.


In an era where consumers are becoming more ingredient-savvy, L’Oreal has made efforts to include nourishing ingredients in their formulations, such as keratin and botanical oils.

However, it’s important to note that some of their products still contain sulfates and parabens, so be sure to read the label if you’re particular about these elements.

Clairol has a more focused range called ‘Natural Instincts’ that boasts of being made with 80% naturally derived ingredients, including coconut oil and aloe vera.

This line is free of ammonia and parabens, making it a good option for those who prefer cleaner ingredients in their hair color.

L’Oreal Excellence Crème vs Clairol Nice ‘n Easy

From the above, you can see both L’Oreal and Clairol are quite popular in the hair coloring industry, and each offers a variety of products.

In this comparison, we’ll zero in on two specific, but widely popular, products from each brand: L’Oreal’s Excellence Crème and Clairol’s Nice ‘n Easy.

Ease of Application

L’Oreal Excellence Crème: This product comes in a no-drip crème formula that makes for a relatively mess-free application.

The package includes a unique brush applicator which allows you to apply the product like a pro. The formula is easy to mix and comes with clear instructions.

Clairol Nice ‘n Easy: This product is also designed for easy application but uses a liquid color formula that can be slightly messier if you’re not careful.

Clairol also includes gloves and an applicator nozzle for simplified usage. However, there’s no custom brush, which some may consider a drawback.

Color Payoff

Excellence Crème offers an extensive range of colors, from natural hues to more vibrant shades. The pigmentation is rich, and the color payoff is generally intense, providing full grey coverage.

Many users commend the product for its multi-tonal color that mimics the natural variations in human hair.

Clairol focuses more on natural-looking colors, aiming to mimic the multi-dimensional tones found in untreated hair.

The color payoff is generally good, though users note it leans towards a more natural finish rather than an intense, saturated look. Grey coverage is also effective, though results may vary depending on your base color.


L’Oreal Excellence Crème: This product prides itself on its Pro-Keratine complex, designed to fortify the hair fiber and lessen damage associated with coloring.

While the formula does include some chemical ingredients, it also incorporates nourishing components aimed at reducing breakage and dryness.

Clairol Nice ‘n Easy: The formula here includes built-in conditioners and is free from ammonia, offering a somewhat gentler coloring experience.

It’s formulated with ME+ technology, which reduces the risk of allergic reactions, a significant consideration for those with sensitive skin or known allergies to hair dye.

Fade Resistance

Known for its long-lasting color, Excellence Crème offers vibrant, fade-resistant results. The formula also includes a post-color conditioner which aids in sealing the color and extending its longevity.

Nice ‘n Easy offers a ColorSeal conditioner aimed at boosting the longevity of the color.

Users have noted that while the color does last, it tends to fade gracefully into a more natural hue over time, particularly in the vibrant shades.

Conclusion: L’Oreal or Clairol Hair Color?

Deciding between L’Oreal and Clairol boils down to personal preferences and specific hair needs. If you seek multi-dimensional color with added hair care benefits, L’Oreal’s technologically advanced formulations may be your best bet.

However, if you’re after a simpler, more budget-friendly option that delivers solid color results, Clairol could be your go-to.

It’s not a matter of which brand is objectively better; it’s about which product aligns most closely with your individual hair goals.

We earn commissions if you purchase thru our link. Majority of products aren’t tested by the site owner (except a few). Content is from the research and feedback of users.